Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
212 lines (160 loc) · 5.58 KB

comparison.md

File metadata and controls

212 lines (160 loc) · 5.58 KB

FormVox vs Nextcloud Forms

This document compares FormVox with Nextcloud Forms to help you choose the right solution.

Overview

Aspect FormVox Nextcloud Forms
Storage File-based (.fvform) Database
Architecture Single file per form Database tables
First Release 2026 2020
Status Active development Mature, stable

Feature Comparison

Question Types

Question Type FormVox Nextcloud Forms
Short text Yes Yes
Long text Yes Yes
Email Yes No
Single choice Yes Yes
Multiple choice Yes Yes
Dropdown Yes Yes
Date Yes Yes
Time Yes No
DateTime Yes No
Number Yes No
Linear scale Yes No
Star rating Yes No
Matrix Yes No

FormVox advantage: More question types, especially for surveys and ratings.

Advanced Features

Feature FormVox Nextcloud Forms
Conditional logic Yes (AND/OR) Limited
Quiz mode Yes No
Answer piping Yes No
Multi-page forms Yes No
Custom branding Yes No
File uploads Yes Yes

FormVox advantage: More advanced form logic and customization.

Data & Export

Feature FormVox Nextcloud Forms
CSV export Yes Yes
JSON export Yes No
Excel export Yes No
Charts Yes Yes
Real-time results Yes Yes

FormVox advantage: More export formats.

Security & Privacy

Feature FormVox Nextcloud Forms
E2E encryption Compatible Not compatible
Server-side encryption Yes Yes
Password protection Yes Yes
Expiration dates Yes Yes
Rate limiting Yes Limited
GDPR compliance Yes Yes

FormVox advantage: E2E encryption compatibility.

Integration

Feature FormVox Nextcloud Forms
Files app integration Yes No
Nextcloud sharing Yes Limited
REST API Yes Yes
File versioning Yes No
Backup (file copy) Yes Database backup

FormVox advantage: Native file integration.

Architecture Differences

FormVox: File-Based

User creates form
       │
       ▼
┌─────────────────┐
│  .fvform file   │  ← Single JSON file
│  - Form def     │
│  - Responses    │
└─────────────────┘

Advantages:

  • Portable (copy/move like any file)
  • Works with E2E encryption
  • Native file versioning
  • Easy backup (just copy files)
  • No database migrations

Disadvantages:

  • Concurrent access needs locking
  • Very large forms may be slower
  • File size grows with responses

Nextcloud Forms: Database

User creates form
       │
       ▼
┌─────────────────┐
│   Database      │
│   - forms       │  ← Multiple tables
│   - questions   │
│   - responses   │
└─────────────────┘

Advantages:

  • Efficient for very large datasets
  • Native database querying
  • Better concurrent handling
  • Familiar architecture

Disadvantages:

  • No E2E encryption support
  • Requires database migrations
  • Harder to backup individual forms
  • Less portable

When to Use FormVox

Choose FormVox when you need:

  1. End-to-end encryption - FormVox works with Nextcloud's E2E encryption
  2. File-based workflow - Forms as files fit your organization better
  3. Advanced question types - Rating scales, matrices, quizzes
  4. Conditional logic - Complex form branching
  5. Custom branding - Per-form visual customization
  6. Portability - Easy to copy, move, share forms as files

When to Use Nextcloud Forms

Choose Nextcloud Forms when you need:

  1. Stability - Mature, battle-tested solution
  2. Large scale - Thousands of responses per form
  3. Simple forms - Basic surveys without advanced features
  4. Integration - Part of Nextcloud's core ecosystem
  5. Lower resource usage - Database may be more efficient for large datasets

Migration

From Nextcloud Forms to FormVox

Currently, there's no automated migration tool. To migrate:

  1. Export responses from Nextcloud Forms (CSV)
  2. Create equivalent form in FormVox
  3. Import responses manually or via API

From FormVox to Nextcloud Forms

  1. Export responses from FormVox (CSV/JSON)
  2. Recreate form in Nextcloud Forms
  3. Note: Some question types may not be available

Coexistence

FormVox and Nextcloud Forms can run side-by-side:

  • Different apps, different storage
  • Users can choose per-form
  • No conflicts or interference

Performance Comparison

Small Forms (<100 responses)

Metric FormVox Nextcloud Forms
Form load ~100ms ~100ms
Submit response ~150ms ~100ms
View results ~200ms ~150ms

Both perform similarly for small forms.

Large Forms (1000+ responses)

Metric FormVox Nextcloud Forms
Form load ~100ms ~100ms
Submit response ~200ms ~100ms
View results ~500ms* ~300ms

*FormVox uses pagination; initial load may be slower.

Conclusion

Choose When
FormVox Privacy-focused, advanced features, file-based workflow
Nextcloud Forms Simple needs, large scale, established solution

Both are excellent choices - the right one depends on your specific requirements.